OXFORD CLIMATE SOCIETY
  • About
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • Our History >
      • Timeline
      • Past Speakers
    • Advisory Board
    • Our Sponsors
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
    • Videos of Past Events
    • Net Zero Home School
    • Student Research Showcase
    • AI Impact Weekend
  • Education
    • The Oxford School of Climate Change
    • Environmental Geography: Climate Change and Policy
    • Global Climate Change: A Summary for Policymakers
    • Philosophy of Climate Change: Climate Ethics
    • Reading Lists
  • Action
    • Act Now >
      • decarbonise oxford
      • At your college
      • At the University
    • Oxford Climate Action Plan
    • College Sustainability Workshops
    • Climate in the Curriculum
  • Media and Arts
    • RISE zine
    • Anthroposphere: The Oxford Climate Review
    • Interdiscplinary Fine Art
    • Freshers Guide
  • Blog
  • Get Involved
    • Elections
    • Subscribe to our Newsletter
  • Alumni Network
  • Networks
    • Researcher Network
  • Contact

the ocs blog

Intersectional Environmentalism: Climate Justice, Environmental Racism and Inclusion in the Environmental Movement

30/1/2021

0 Comments

 
By Nayah Thu
Picture
Img: Becker1999
On January 26th 2021, Greta Thunberg again criticised politicians and business leaders for inaction on the climate crisis in a video message to the Davos Agenda week, [1] aimed at an audience of mostly wealthy, White* men – a group wholly unrepresentative of the world’s population. It’s not just Davos that struggles with issues of racism and lack of representation - so too does the mainstream environmental movement. Even as the disproportionate effects of climate change on developing nations are becoming widely understood, there is insufficient focus on amplifying Black and Brown voices within the movement. In order to fairly and effectively fight the climate crisis, environmental actors need to embrace “intersectional environmentalism” and actively work to reach social justice. [2]
In 2014, a police officer fatally shot Michael Brown, an unarmed Black teenager, in a St. Louis suburb. Missouri native Leah Thomas returned to her environmental science degree shaken by the tragedy. She realised that even when facts about the disproportionate effect of environmental injustices on Black and Brown communities were covered, “they’d brush over it and go back to talking about saving the salmon.” Eventually, she coined the term “intersectional environmentalism” – adapting  Kimberlé Crenshaw’s framework of “intersectional feminism” to describe how “the same systems of oppression are at play in both environmental and racial justice sphere”. [3] 
When she defined it in her viral Environmentalists for Black Lives Matter social media graphic last year, the term entered the mainstream, and helped grow the movement towards self-reflection about inclusivity in the environmental movement. As Thomas said in the Instagram post that started it all: “It is not an optional ‘add-on’ to environmentalism. It is unfair to opt in and out of caring about racial injustices when many of us cannot.” [4]
With Joe Biden nominating Michael Reagan to be the first ever Black head of the United States EPA (Environmental Protection Agency), [5] focus is returning to the overwhelming Whiteness of the environmental movement and its leadership. As Jessie Sitnick acknowledges, lack of representation in leadership leads to problems in reaching those audiences who are under-represented, thanks to “the inaccessibility of the language we use, the cultural references we make, the baked-in assumptions that what matters most to White mainstream environmentalists should resonate the same way with everyone else.” [6] A 2014 report from Green 2.0, a non-profit diversity initiative, found that, within participating environmental NGOs, 88 percent of staff and 95 percent of boards were White. [7]
This extreme lack of diversity stems from a lack of recruitment and inclusion in the environmental community, where, according to Dorceta Taylor, a professor of Environmental Sociology at the University of Michigan, some of the “white males that occupy the leadership positions…don’t even have environmental degrees” [8].  Taylor urges people to “ get over the myth that students of colour are not qualified, they’re not educated enough, and they’re not taking the appropriate course work.” It is the responsibility of those in power to make room for the voices and perspectives needed to effectively fight issues of environmental injustice. 
The overwhelming lack of consideration for the voices and experiences of Black, Brown and Indigenous people is nothing new. In 1982, Benjamin Chavis coined the term “environmental racism”, meaning“racial discrimination in environmental policy-making, the enforcement of regulations and laws, the deliberate targeting of communities of colour for toxic waste facilities, the official sanctioning of the life-threatening presence of poisons and pollutants in our communities, and the history of excluding people of colour from leadership of the ecology movements”. [9] He and others, including “father of environmental justice,”[10] Dr. Robert Bullard, have investigated targeted and widespread policies which have caused concrete harm to communities of colour. For example,  between the 1930s and 1978, 82 % of all of the city of Houston, Texas’ waste was dumped in Black neighbourhoods, despite only 25% of the population being Black. [11] 
This is not an issue that is confined to the United States. For example, a 2018 Natural England and ONS report found that White Britons were nearly 20% more likely to regularly access green spaces on a regular weekly basis than their BAME** counterparts, while another report in 2019 found that BAME Britons were up to 29% more likely than their White compatriots to be exposed to particulate matter pollution. [12]  As Thomas puts it, “the environmentalism that we have now that has been thought of as being “progressive” has only been progressive for one group of people and that’s not fair.” [3] Without a concrete focus on racial justice in the environmental movement, which is only possible by amplifying the voices of those affected, climate action will only end up exacerbating inequality around the world. 
Beyond environmental racism, the mainstream environmental movement suffers from a case of severe cultural appropriation. From the White-washing of vegan and vegetarian diets in the media, despite the fact that three times as many non-White than White Americans identify as vegetarian, [13] to the many other sustainable practices co-opted from communities of colour and repackaged for the White mainstream, this trend of cultural appropriation and a lack of acknowledgment of the roots of sustainable practices feeds into systems of oppression and marginalisation without allowing for meaningful cross-cultural communication.
As long as White environmental activists continue to take what is convenient for them, without committing themselves to intersectional environmentalism, anti-racism, and listening to and amplifying the voices of Black, Brown and Indigenous environmentalists, climate action that is just and which serves all members of humanity will never be achieved.



[1] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/01/greta-thunberg-climate-response-rogoff-greenpeace-unccd/ 
[2] https://www.intersectionalenvironmentalist.com/ 
[3]https://assembly.malala.org/stories/climate-activist-leah-thomas-on-intersectional-environmentalism 
[4] https://www.instagram.com/p/CAvaxdRJRxu/ 
[5] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-03621-6 
[6]https://argylepr.com/insight-and-inspiration/green-and-white-why-we-must-dismantle-racism-in-the-environmental-sector/  
[7]http://orgs.law.harvard.edu/els/files/2014/02/FullReport_Green2.0_FINALReducedSize.pdf
[8]https://e360.yale.edu/features/how-green-groups-became-so-white-and-what-to-do-about-it
[9] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/07/what-is-environmental-racism-pollution-covid-systemic/ 
[10]https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/21/what-is-environmental-injustice-and-why-is-the-guardian-covering-it 
[11]https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/dec/20/robert-bullard-interview-environmental-justice-civil-rights-movement 
[12] https://impakter.com/environmental-racism-why-does-it-still-exist/ 
[13]https://www.vice.com/en/article/bv833z/dear-white-vegans-stop-appropriating-food 
* We have made an editorial decision to capitalise all terms denoting race (i.e. White, Black and Brown) as this highlights the fact that race is socially constructed. By choosing to capitalise the term White, we are choosing to acknowledge that Whiteness is not a neutral default or ‘natural’ category, while Blackness and Brownness are other. Instead, Whiteness is just as much a social created category. We realise that there is live debate surrounding this issue, and welcome your views on the matter. For more information on the debate, we recommend heading here and here. These are starting points, and there is much more information out there for those who are interested in learning more. 
**An acronym used in the UK to refer to people from ‘Black and Ethnic Minority’ backgrounds. It is a heavily contested term (e.g. see here, here and here as starting points), but we use it here as this was the category used in the studies cited.
0 Comments

Race and Climate; Compounding Injustices

15/11/2020

2 Comments

 
Event summary by Bridget Stuart
Picture
During this event, we had three brilliant and distinguished women discuss the complex intersection of race and climate.
 
Elizabeth Yeampierre is an attorney and climate justice activist leader born and raised in New York, with Puerto Rican heritage and African and Indigenous ancestry. She is the Executive Director of UPROSE, Brooklyn’s oldest community-led organisation. In her speech, she imparted a resonant message: we cannot tackle climate change and race as separate issues.
 
The lives of non-white communities around the world are disproportionally impacted by pollution, toxic air, extreme weather events, which—when compounded with poorer healthcare and less support from organisational bodies—makes them increasingly vulnerable to the negative effects of climate breakdown. And  yet, Elizabeth posed the stark question, “Why do people care more about polar bears than people of colour?"
 
The roots of the climate activism can be found in the social justice movement, and a just transition must be led by front-line communities, striving for people-centred solutions towards a resilient, regenerative and equal society.
 
Dr Ariadne Collins is a lecturer in International Relations at St Andrews University, and her work lies in market-based conservation and post-colonial development. She focused on the countries of Guyana and Surinam, and how their 500 years of colonial histories need to be recognised as structural conditions in order for conservation interventions to be effective. Detailing the histories of both nations, Ariadne critiqued the UN-led REDD+ programme, highlighting how the programme side-steps the colonial past.
  
Archana Soreng is an environmental activist and UN Youth Advisor on Climate Change, who belongs to the Khadia Tribe in Sundergarh, India. She started off by talking about how the colonial, extractivist, developmental worldview has been demeaning and destroying indigenous people and their ways of life for centuries. These indigenous communities are the least responsible for the climate crisis, yet it is these people who are both disproportionately suffering from the negative effects of climate change and who are on the front-line of climate justice activism and action.
 
Archana made the point that the traditional expertise and first-hand perspective of indigenous people is extremely valuable in the fight against climate change. These marginalised voices must be included and listened to, if we are to create real change.
   
Here are some take away points from the Q+A:
  • People of colour on the frontlines of climate justice activism need to be helped and supported, without being supplanted. This can be achieved by forming just relationships.
  • People in the ‘Global North’, who want to be ‘allies’ must think about the far-reaching consequences of our actions, try to change the way we behave and try to influence policies which affect countries in the ‘Global South’.
  • To fully understand and fight injustice, we cannot focus on a single issue in isolation. Instead, we must recognise the web of interconnected systemic problems and extend our action to other systems of oppression. This requires shared leadership and solutions from collective action.
2 Comments

    OCS Media Team

    The latest in climate science and policy from the OCS team.

    Join the team!

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    May 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017

    Categories

    All
    Adaptation
    BEIS
    Climate Justice
    Communication
    COP23
    COP24
    COP26
    Coronavirus
    DEFRA
    Eco Guide
    Economics
    Event Summary
    Extreme Weather
    Food
    Food Reviews
    Fossil Fuels
    Gender
    Government
    Impacts
    International
    Local
    Michael Gove
    Nature
    Oceans
    Plastic
    Policy
    Pollution
    Race
    Solutions
    UK
    UNFCCC
    USA
    Women And Climate Change

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • About
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • Our History >
      • Timeline
      • Past Speakers
    • Advisory Board
    • Our Sponsors
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
    • Videos of Past Events
    • Net Zero Home School
    • Student Research Showcase
    • AI Impact Weekend
  • Education
    • The Oxford School of Climate Change
    • Environmental Geography: Climate Change and Policy
    • Global Climate Change: A Summary for Policymakers
    • Philosophy of Climate Change: Climate Ethics
    • Reading Lists
  • Action
    • Act Now >
      • decarbonise oxford
      • At your college
      • At the University
    • Oxford Climate Action Plan
    • College Sustainability Workshops
    • Climate in the Curriculum
  • Media and Arts
    • RISE zine
    • Anthroposphere: The Oxford Climate Review
    • Interdiscplinary Fine Art
    • Freshers Guide
  • Blog
  • Get Involved
    • Elections
    • Subscribe to our Newsletter
  • Alumni Network
  • Networks
    • Researcher Network
  • Contact