OXFORD CLIMATE SOCIETY
  • About
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • Our History
    • Advisory Board
    • Our Sponsors
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Videos of Past Events
  • Education
    • The Oxford School of Climate Change
    • Capstone Projects
    • Climate Change and Policy Lecture series
    • COP information
    • Climate Library
  • Action
    • Sustainability Action Guide
    • Decarbonise Oxford
    • College Sustainability Workshops
    • Legacy Campaigns >
      • Sustainability in the Curriculum
      • Oxford Climate Action Plan
  • Media and Arts
    • RISE zine
    • Anthroposphere: The Oxford Climate Review
    • Interdiscplinary Fine Art
  • Blog
    • Articles >
      • International Climate Policy
      • Global Perspectives
      • What you need to know about...
      • Past Blogs
    • Event summaries
  • Get Involved
    • Join Our Teams
    • RISE Submissions
    • Subscribe to our Newsletter
  • Alumni Network
  • Contact
  • Donate

Past Blogs

A variety of blog posts

Storytelling and Climate Activism

5/7/2020

0 Comments

 
Event summary by Bianca Pasca
Picture
When it comes to issues of climate justice, the need for educating people about the problem means we often hear activists calling us to ‘listen to the science’. But facts and numbers may be hard to swallow if they don’t manage to speak to us on an emotional level—to make us understand the context and the urgency of the matter. We need to feel that we are characters in this story, who have a voice, and can shape the ending.

The Storytelling and Climate Activism event brings together two people experienced in crafting compelling narratives that speak truthfully and emotionally about the issues of climate change.

Bill McKibben is an author and environmentalist, with a history of public activism dating back to the publication of his first book, The End of Nature, in 1989. He is a co-founder of 350.org, the first global grassroots climate-change movement. As the Schumann Distinguished Scholar in Environmental Studies at Middlebury College, he has written nearly 20 books and won numerous prizes for his environmental work, including the 2014 Right Livelihood Prize, sometimes referred to as the ‘alternative Nobel’.

Megan Mayhew Bergman is an author, journalist, essayist and critic. She has written two short-story collections and has a novel forthcoming in the near future. She has worked for the ‘Climate Changed’ column about the American South for the Guardian in 2018/19. She teaches literature and environmental writing, also at Middlebury College, and serves there as the director of the Bread Loaf Environmental Writers' Conference, as well. Her work has been recognised with awards like the Phil Reed Environmental Writing Award in 2020.
 
Opening the discussion, Megan quoted a Latin phrase she feels to be very important in the current context of the double crises of the climate crisis and systemic racism: Esse quam videri (“To be, rather than to seem”). She believes storytelling must be done from an incredibly sincere place, working on a very human level. Complexity and multiple perspectives have to be honoured in any story covering climate change. But narratives also have to be accessible, making the conversation easy to join.

Bill said he believes deep stories can be told from the numbers and science— that is the idea behind the 350.org project. The number refers to a number of parts per million of CO2  in the atmosphere (although we have now reached 415 parts per million) and speaks to the urgency of the matter, conveying feelings and telling the story of climate damage.

In his opening comments, he emphasised the importance of providing a platform for the voices not yet listened to by the mainstream, through projects like the 'Passing the Mic' section of the New Yorker, which Bill has been involved in writing. Bill spoke about how the climate movement has grown since he first published his first book, The End of Nature in 1989, a time when a lot of the articles about climate change were written by him and a small group of others.

Some people say that climate change is too complex a concept to be portrayed in a story. What do you think about this?
  • Megan’s opinion is that it takes a lot of knowledge to be able to talk about big, deep systemic issues. Personally, she prefers to contribute at a very specific story level, where her knowledge and skills can be best put to use. She emphasized the importance of knowing how to craft a narrative by building both a rational and an emotional case, that is, presenting the science, but also why people should care about it. This is what sparks a desire to change behaviour.
  • Bill, on the other hand, believes you don’t need to know that much, because it’s not a complicated story. For him, the main point is how humanity discovered the uses for burning fossil fuels. He said it is an archetypal story: the villain is the fossil fuel industry; the heroes are the millions of people working to help bring about change. He said it is most important to grasp the gist of the complex situation.

Conceptions of good and bad are based on very different world-views and values. Many people would say that ‘the villain’ is a lack of global governance, whereas others see the problem as capitalism and its focus on growth, leading to injustices. Yet another view might see radical environmentalism as the problem. So, what role do you think storytelling can play in bringing people with such different perspectives together to fight for climate justice?

  • Bill remarked that journalistic investigation has revealed the that the fossil fuel industry has known about the effects of its actions—that is, climate change—even back in the 1980s. For example, Exxon had an experienced scientific staff who predicted rising sea levels, which led the company to begin building its drilling rigs higher to compensate. Instead of speaking up about these problems, the industry chose to sow doubt about the credibility of climate change science. For a long time, only scientists like former NASA climate researcher James Hansen spoke up, raising awareness. There would be fewer people denying the existence of climate issues today if CEOs of the fossil fuel companies hadn't denied the truth for so long.
  • Talking about his experience of chaining himself at a petrol station, to expose Exxon’s lies, Bill pointed out that civil disobedience is a kind of storytelling which draws attention to important issues. So, storytelling is something that can be done both on the written page and through actions.
  • Megan considered the idea from a political point of view: sadly, in the United States, climate change became politicised during the Reagan era, being seen as a ‘liberal buzz word’. This means that in some contexts, climate scientists have to find other ways of conveying the information in order for people to listen. For example, without direct mention of the climate crisis, they might talk of rising sea levels or changing weather patterns.

How can we tell stories that are inclusive without also pandering to the climate denial movement? In other words, how can we navigate the duality of the fact that the voices of people who are excluded from our stories can also be the voices that deny the existence of a climate crisis?
  • Megan referred to a 2015 Pew Research survey, which found that the Latinx and POC population in the US are more likely to believe that climate change is a man-made phenomenon than white male evangelicals. The latter group of people are still at the top of most power structures in the South—climate denial is usually not the narrative of marginalized voices. In Megan’s view, it is important that training and opportunities are made available, to make the environmental writing and communication space accessible and open.
  • Bill was also of the opinion that the problem lies with powerful people who don’t want to do anything about the problem; people who benefit from the status quo, rather than it being the less powerful not believing in the existence of the problem. Instead of trying to change the minds of about 30% of people who might never be persuaded, it is important that the 70% of people who are aware of the issues to be willing, active and vocal in the fight.
 
For the full seminar, head to our YouTube channel where this and every other talk from Trinity term's seminar series can be viewed: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCOoksFYBCHqZWwVBU9qewZg
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    OCS Media Team

    The latest in climate science, policy, perspectives and more from the OCS team.

    Archives

    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    May 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017

    Categories

    All
    Adaptation
    BEIS
    Climate Justice
    Communication
    COP23
    COP24
    COP26
    Coronavirus
    DEFRA
    Eco Guide
    Economics
    Event Summary
    Extreme Weather
    Food
    Food Reviews
    Fossil Fuels
    Gender
    Global Perspectives
    Government
    Impacts
    International
    Local
    Nature
    Oceans
    Plastic
    Policy
    Pollution
    Race
    Solutions
    UK
    UNFCCC
    USA
    Women And Climate Change

    RSS Feed

Developing informed climate leaders
www.oxfordclimatesociety.com
  • About
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • Our History
    • Advisory Board
    • Our Sponsors
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Videos of Past Events
  • Education
    • The Oxford School of Climate Change
    • Capstone Projects
    • Climate Change and Policy Lecture series
    • COP information
    • Climate Library
  • Action
    • Sustainability Action Guide
    • Decarbonise Oxford
    • College Sustainability Workshops
    • Legacy Campaigns >
      • Sustainability in the Curriculum
      • Oxford Climate Action Plan
  • Media and Arts
    • RISE zine
    • Anthroposphere: The Oxford Climate Review
    • Interdiscplinary Fine Art
  • Blog
    • Articles >
      • International Climate Policy
      • Global Perspectives
      • What you need to know about...
      • Past Blogs
    • Event summaries
  • Get Involved
    • Join Our Teams
    • RISE Submissions
    • Subscribe to our Newsletter
  • Alumni Network
  • Contact
  • Donate